Kraken Parent Payward Sues Custodian Etana Over Alleged $25 Million Ponzi-Like Misappropriation
Payward filed a second amended complaint in Colorado federal court alleging Etana Custody and CEO Dion Russell ran a Ponzi-like scheme, misappropriating $25M+ in Kraken reserve funds through falsified account statements and risky credit bets. Etana entered liquidation in November 2025.
Payward, the parent company of crypto exchange Kraken, filed a second amended complaint on May 4 in the US District Court for the District of Colorado alleging that former custody partner Etana Custody and its CEO Dion Brandon Russell misappropriated more than $25 million in Kraken reserve funds through what the filing describes as a "Ponzi-like" scheme. Etana had entered statutory liquidation in November 2025 after Colorado regulators issued cease-and-desist and suspension orders.
The Lawsuit
Payward's complaint alleges that Etana marketed itself to Kraken as a segregated, bankruptcy-remote custodian — the standard representation that custody firms make to institutional clients to ensure that customer funds cannot be used for the custodian's own operations. Instead, the filing alleges, Etana commingled Kraken's reserve funds with its own operating capital, deployed client assets into illiquid, high-risk credit bets, and papered over a growing funding hole with falsified account statements. The complaint characterizes the scheme as Ponzi-like because Etana allegedly used fresh inflows to cover withdrawals from earlier clients rather than maintaining segregated reserves.
The flashpoint came in April 2025, when Kraken attempted to withdraw approximately $25 million from its reserve funds held at Etana. According to the filing, Etana delayed the payout by claiming "reconciliation issues" that Payward characterizes as fictitious. At least $16 million of the shortfall is alleged to be tied to a promissory note Etana issued to Seabury Trade Capital, which subsequently defaulted — leaving Etana unable to meet Kraken's withdrawal request without fresh capital from other sources.
What Kraken Alleges
The second amended complaint names CEO Dion Brandon Russell personally, alleging he directed the fraudulent scheme and falsified the account statements that masked the custody shortfall from Kraken's compliance team. The complaint seeks recovery of the full $25 million plus damages. The court-appointed receiver overseeing Etana's liquidation has reported current cash holdings of approximately $6.83 million against liabilities exceeding $26 million — meaning Kraken's claim represents the overwhelming majority of Etana's total liabilities, and recovery of the full amount is structurally dependent on the receiver's ability to claw back assets from Seabury Trade Capital and other parties named in the filing.
Etana was a specialized custody firm that served primarily crypto exchanges and institutional traders, with Kraken as its largest client. The firm received regulatory approval from the Colorado Division of Banking in 2019. Colorado's cease-and-desist order in 2025 cited violations of the Colorado Money Transmitters Act and evidence of operating capital deficiencies consistent with Payward's allegations.
Crypto.newsLooking Ahead
The Etana case is a direct illustration of the systemic risk in crypto custody: even with Colorado banking regulation, a custodian could allegedly falsify account statements for long enough to run a significant funding shortfall. For exchanges relying on third-party custodians for reserve funds, the Etana case is a due-diligence failure analysis — what verification mechanisms would have caught the shortfall earlier? Proof-of-reserves attestations, third-party audits, and real-time API-level balance verification are all controls that Etana apparently circumvented. The question for the broader industry is whether any regulated custodian should be trusted without cryptographic proof of reserves, not just accounting attestations.
Crypto + AI policy moves, the day they land — subscribe →
How we report: This article cites primary sources, regulatory filings, and on-chain data where available. BlockAI News uses AI tools to assist with research and first-draft generation; every article is reviewed and edited by a human editor before publication. Read our full How We Report page, Editorial Policy, AI Use Policy, and Corrections Policy.
